Choosing between two niches when both look viable
Published · Last reviewed
How do I choose between two consulting niches?
Run the twenty-names test on each. Write down twenty real, named organisations that have the problem and could pay to fix it. The niche where you stall at eight names is not a niche, it is an interest. If both clear twenty, pick on two tiebreakers: which problem is recurring and expensive rather than one-off and annoying, and which buyer you can already reach — a warm introduction beats a better market every time at the start. Then give the winner ninety days undivided. Splitting attention across two niches is the most common way first-time consultants spend a year sounding generic to everyone.
Most first-time consultants look for a niche by asking what they are interested in. That produces a topic, not a niche, and a topic cannot be sold. A niche is three things at once: a type of buyer, a problem that costs them money on a repeating basis, and evidence that you have already solved it. Miss any one of the three and you get a positioning line that sounds fine and generates no calls.
The fastest way in is to work backwards from what people already came to you for. In your last job, what did colleagues interrupt you about? What did your manager route to you specifically, because you were faster or more reliable at it than anyone else? That is not a hobby. It is a demonstrated capability with witnesses — and witnesses become references.
Start from the work, not the market
Write down the last five pieces of work you are genuinely proud of. For each one, note who benefited, what would have gone wrong without you, and roughly what that outcome was worth. You are looking for the same buyer showing up more than once, or the same problem showing up more than once. Two hits on either axis is a niche worth testing.
If the list is all over the place, narrow by buyer first, not by service. "Operations leaders at 20–100 person B2B software companies" is a niche you can name people in. "Process improvement" is a category with no address.
The test: can you name twenty of them?
The practical test for a real niche is whether you can sit down and list twenty specific companies or people who fit it, by name, without research. If you can, you have a niche and an outreach list on the same page. If you cannot get past six, the definition is too abstract — usually because it names a service rather than a buyer.
The second test: does the problem recur? One-off problems are hard to build a practice on, because every project starts from zero. Problems that come back every quarter, every funding round, or every time the team doubles are the ones that produce repeat work and referrals.
Narrow is not the same as small
The most common objection is that narrowing cuts off business. In the first year it does the opposite. A narrow claim is the only kind a stranger can act on. Someone who reads "I help early-stage fintechs pass their first SOC 2 without hiring a compliance lead" knows within four seconds whether to reply. Someone who reads "I help businesses improve their operations" has nothing to react to, and will not reply at all.
You can always widen later. Practices widen naturally through referrals — a happy client introduces you to a neighbour in an adjacent industry and the definition stretches on its own. Practices almost never narrow successfully after starting broad, because the broad claim is what brought in every conversation you are having.
Pick one and give it ninety days
A niche is a bet, not a permanent identity. Write it as one line, use it in every introduction and every email for ninety days, and count the replies. Ninety days of a consistent claim beats a year of quiet refinement, because the market can only respond to a claim it has actually seen.
Day rates · free, no email
What each of these niches actually pays
A niche is only half the decision. The other half is what it bills, because a niche that fits you and prices badly is still a pay cut. Each page below publishes the day-rate band for one field, who signs the invoice in it, and the three offers that field's work is usually bought in.
- What should an operations consultant charge?$650–$2,100 a day
- What should a marketing consultant charge?$625–$2,000 a day
- What should a finance consultant charge?$750–$2,375 a day
- What should a software consultant charge?$825–$2,650 a day
- What should an HR consultant charge?$575–$1,825 a day
- What should a strategy consultant charge?$725–$2,275 a day
- Operations consultant day rate at 6–9 years$575–$2,175 a day
- Marketing consultant day rate at 6–9 years$550–$2,075 a day
Not your field, or not your rung? All 93 rate pages are indexed on one page — thirteen fields, six experience levels each — and the free rate calculator works out your own four answers in the browser, with no email and no card.
Your next step · free preview · $3 or $29
Reading the answer is the easy half.
Knowing what to do and having it written down in your own words are different jobs, and the second one is where most first-time consultants stall. The next page does the first half of it for free: one field, no email and no card, and your niche, your buyer and your proof line are on the screen in under a minute.
Free on the next page, before you pay anything
- Your most sellable consulting niche, named — and why it beats the more obvious one
- A sellability score out of 10, with the reasoning behind it
- The buyer who pays for it: role, company stage, and the moment they start looking
- The proof line to lead with, written from your own background
- The biggest gap in how you're positioned today
- One move to make this week
$29 one-time · free preview first · no subscription
$29 writes the whole launch package from your own background: a one-line positioning statement, three productized offers scoped and priced, your bio rewritten, a cold email with two follow-ups, a one-page proposal template and a 30-day plan to land your first three clients. One payment, no subscription, on your own order page in minutes and emailed as a PDF — and the first half of it is written on the next page for free, before you decide anything.
See my kit preview free — then $29No questions asked
Read the whole kit, and if it isn't worth $29, email [email protected] and we refund it. No questions asked.
Or read one complete kit first, free — every offer, price, email, the proposal and the 30-day plan, nothing gated.
Just the priced offers · $3 one-time
$3 buys the decision on its own: three positioned offers built for your niche, each scoped and priced with what it can realistically charge, the buyer who pays for them profiled in full, and every gap in how you are positioned with what to do about it. No positioning line, no bio, no outreach, no proposal and no 30-day plan — those are the $29 kit.
Get my niche check — $3Opens the card form here · one question afterOne payment, no subscription. It lands on your own order page in minutes and is emailed to you — and if you have not run the free verdict yet, we ask the one question it needs on that page.